
Why Do Americans Eat Turkey on Thanksgiving?
Why turkey became the Thanksgiving meal: what was served in 1621, how Sarah Josepha Hale and Lincoln shaped the holiday, and how to share a turkey this year.
By Embrace Relief Team · Updated November 13, 2026
The useful part before the long read.
The 1621 harvest feast in Plymouth included venison and wild fowl; we do not know for sure that turkey was served.
Turkey is native to North America and large enough to feed a family at one table.
Sarah Josepha Hale described turkey dinners and campaigned for a national Thanksgiving for years.
A $25 gift provides a Thanksgiving turkey to a family through the Embrace USA Turkey Drive.
Americans eat turkey on Thanksgiving mostly because of 19th-century custom, not because of a single historical meal. Wild turkeys were plentiful in North America, one bird could feed a whole family, and writers such as Sarah Josepha Hale helped turn the roast turkey into the center of the national holiday that Abraham Lincoln proclaimed in 1863.
Was turkey served at the first Thanksgiving?
Only two short written accounts of the 1621 Plymouth harvest gathering survive. Edward Winslow wrote that the colonists went "fowling" and that the Wampanoag guests brought five deer. William Bradford later wrote that the colony had a supply of wild turkeys that autumn. So the meal had venison and wild birds, which may have included ducks, geese and turkey. Historians agree that much of today's menu, including pumpkin pie and mashed potatoes, came later.
Why turkey became the main dish
It was available
Wild turkeys lived across much of eastern North America, and farm-raised turkeys became common in the 1800s. Late November was a natural time to serve a bird raised over the summer.
It feeds a crowd
Thanksgiving is a family meal. One turkey can feed a large table, which made it more practical than chickens, which were kept for eggs, or cows, which were kept for milk.
Writers and presidents made it a tradition
Sarah Josepha Hale, the editor of a popular women's magazine, wrote about roast turkey as the centerpiece of a Thanksgiving dinner and spent years asking presidents to create a national holiday. When Lincoln proclaimed a national day of thanksgiving in 1863, the turkey dinner Hale had described was already familiar to many readers. Over time it became the standard menu.
The presidential turkey pardon
Presidents received gift turkeys for many decades. The White House turkey "pardon" became a formal yearly ceremony in 1989 under President George H. W. Bush. Today the National Thanksgiving Turkey is presented at the White House each November and sent to live out its life on a farm.
Other Thanksgiving foods and where they come from
| Dish | Background |
|---|---|
| Cranberry sauce | Cranberries are native to North America; sweetened sauce became common in the 1800s. |
| Stuffing | Filling a bird with bread and herbs is an old European cooking method. |
| Pumpkin pie | Pumpkins were grown by Native peoples; pie recipes appear in American cookbooks from the late 1700s. |
| Mashed potatoes | A later addition; potatoes were not part of the 1621 meal. |
Help a family put a turkey on the table
For many families in the United States, a holiday meal is hard to afford. Embrace USA, Embrace Relief's U.S. program, runs a Thanksgiving Turkey Drive that delivers turkeys to families in need before Thanksgiving. A $25 gift provides a turkey for one family.
Related reading: When is Thanksgiving 2026? · The meaning of Thanksgiving
Frequently asked questions
Why do Americans eat turkey on Thanksgiving?
Turkey was plentiful in North America, one bird can feed a whole family, and 19th-century writers such as Sarah Josepha Hale made roast turkey the center of the Thanksgiving dinner that became a national holiday in 1863.
Did the Pilgrims eat turkey at the first Thanksgiving?
Possibly. Accounts of the 1621 feast mention wild fowl and five deer, and William Bradford wrote that wild turkeys were plentiful that autumn, but no record confirms turkey was on the table.
What was eaten at the first Thanksgiving in 1621?
The written accounts mention venison brought by the Wampanoag and wild fowl hunted by the colonists. Corn and seafood were also common foods in the area at the time.
When did the presidential turkey pardon start?
Presidents received turkeys for decades, but the pardon became a formal yearly White House ceremony in 1989 under President George H. W. Bush.
How can I donate a Thanksgiving turkey?
You can give $25 to the Embrace USA Thanksgiving Turkey Drive, which provides a turkey to a family in need before Thanksgiving.